View Issue Details
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0003164||unreal||ircd||public||2006-12-25 23:14||2007-01-27 09:53|
|Target Version||Fixed in Version||3.3-alpha0|
|Summary||0003164: A way to test the config file (from the command line or without having to actually rehash)|
|Description||I think it would be very nice (and relatively easy to implement based on how it already does a syntax check first) a way to test the config file for errors without actually having to start/rehash the server to find out. it would be nice to be able to do this via the unreal script from the command line, like "./unreal testconf", and from IRC (/rehash -test maybe?)|
this would be extremely useful to make sure that the conf file has the correct syntax, but not actually require that any changes take place :)
|Tags||No tags attached.|
|3rd party modules|
Actually, this would be totally bad! ;P
a few reasons:
1) we shouldnt have to test a users config file, if they read the docs and edited the config properly they wouldnt have trouble
2) it would take the same time for it to read the config file and show errors the same way it does when you currently do ./unreal start so, basically you're doing the same thing, just with a different command
3) if it doesnt show you the errors, it will paste them in your logs, if you dont have that enabled, its not our problem.
maybe its just me, but I think this is a bad idea and a useless one, sorry
all your 3 statements really make no sense to me, and you must not have read my reasoning behind why its extremely useful.
1) we shouldnt have to test a users config file, if they read the docs and edited the config properly they wouldnt have trouble <--- what kind of logic is that? no matter how much you read the docs you can always make mistakes, like leaveing out a ; for example, or misspelling something.
2) it would take the same time for it to read the config file and show errors the same way it does when you currently do ./unreal start so, basically you're doing the same thing, just with a different command <--- as i already stated, the point would be so that you don't have to start the ircd in order to test if its config file has the correct syntax.
3) if it doesnt show you the errors, it will paste them in your logs, if you dont have that enabled, its not our problem. <--- again, you did not read anything that i said, the whole point would be so that you DON'T have to rehash to find any errors, sometimes you don't want the changes you did to take effect immediately but want to make sure that when you do rehash that you won't run into any problems
next time read the whole report
True about making mistakes, but as I said, .unreal start will tell you that.
and the point in not having to start the ircd doesnt make much sense. I'm sure you could write a 3rd party program for this by yourself without unreal coming with one.
3) the part of the effects not taking immediate effect is a good point, a point i like. Sort of like adding someone to the team but not quite letting him in until all servers have it in their configs, then you can rehash at once. But im still not sure if I like it. I dunno...if i had it i would probably use it ;P but not sure
and i did read the whole report
Note that, while 'testing' might seem quite "light", it actually means you'll have to load modules, initialize, etc. Just to say, it's not some simple syntax checking or anything :P. Then again, you know, it's just that I would have to code it... grin.
Anyway, when I upgrade and the current ("old") ircd is running, I always run "./unreal start" to see any errors. And indeed, often I do find errors (missing certs, missing modules, permissions bad, etc). So I'm quite in favor of some ./unreal configtest (like apache and other daemons).
'/REHASH -test' is a similar story. Though in that case, I didn't see the use at first, but as explained in previous comments it can be very useful (when you need to be sure a rehash succeeds, due to mass-rehash/time/whatever).
Whether this is for 3.3* or 3.2.6, I don't know. Depends on the impact.
EDIT: just to avoid some confusion, other coders may code this as well of course, it's not assigned to me.
Made ./unreal configtest to test config file.
/rehash -test is not necessary and it's too hard (very very hard).
|2006-12-25 23:14||djGrrr||New Issue|
|2006-12-26 23:58||Bricker||Note Added: 0012909|
|2006-12-27 06:55||djGrrr||Note Added: 0012910|
|2006-12-27 06:57||djGrrr||Note Edited: 0012910|
|2006-12-27 13:06||Bricker||Note Added: 0012916|
|2006-12-28 10:15||syzop||Note Added: 0012931|
|2006-12-28 10:15||syzop||Status||new => acknowledged|
|2006-12-28 10:15||syzop||Note Edited: 0012931|
|2007-01-23 06:55||Trocotronic||Status||acknowledged => assigned|
|2007-01-23 06:55||Trocotronic||Assigned To||=> Trocotronic|
|2007-01-27 09:53||Trocotronic||Status||assigned => resolved|
|2007-01-27 09:53||Trocotronic||Fixed in Version||=> 3.3-alpha0|
|2007-01-27 09:53||Trocotronic||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2007-01-27 09:53||Trocotronic||Note Added: 0013120|